Prospective observational study on assessing the hemodynamic relevance of patent ductus arteriosus with frequency domain near-infrared spectroscopy

Abstract

Background

What constitutes a hemodynamically relevant patent ductus arteriosus (hrPDA) in preterm infants is unclear. Different clinical and echocardiographic parameters are used, but a gold standard definition is lacking.

Our objective was to evaluate associations between regional cerebral tissue oxygen saturation (rcStO₂), fraction of tissue oxygen extraction (rcFtO₂E) measured by frequency domain near-infrared spectroscopy (fd-NIRS) and their correlation to echocardiographic, Doppler-ultrasound, and clinical parameters in preterm infants with and without a hrPDA.

Methods

In this prospective observational study, 22 infants < 1500 g (mean [± SD]: gestational age 28.6 [±1.8] weeks, birth weight 1076 [±284] g, median (interquartile range) postnatal age at measurement 7.6 (4.6–12.9) d) with a clinical suspicion of hrPDA were analysed.

Twelve infants had left-to-right shunt through PDA, and in 6 of these the PDA was classified as hrPDA based on pre-defined clinical and echocardiographic criteria. fd-NIRS, echocardiographic and Doppler-ultrasound examinations were performed. After identification of blood hemoglobin (Hb) as confounding factor, rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E were corrected for this effect.

Results

Overall mean ± standard deviation (normalised to a median Hb of 13.8 mg/dl) was 57 ±5% for rcStO₂ and 0.39 ±0.05 for rcFtO₂E. Comparing no-hrPDA with hrPDA infants, there were no significant differences in mean rcStO₂ (58 ±5% vs. 54 ±5%; p = .102), but in mean rcFtO₂E (0.38 ±0.05 vs. 0.43 ±0.05; p = .038). Echocardiographic parameter and Doppler indices did not correlate with cerebral oxygenation.

Conclusion

Oxygen transport capacity of the blood may confound NIRS data interpretation. Cerebral oxygenation determined by fd-NIRS provided additional information for PDA treatment decisions not offered by routine investigations. Whether indicating PDA therapy based on echocardiography complemented by data on cerebral oxygenation results in better outcomes should be investigated in future studies.

Background

Screening for, and therapy of, patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) in preterm infants is associated with decreased mortality and morbidity [1]. However, there is little evidence as to which parameters define a PDA that requires treatment, i.e. is hemodynamically relevant (hrPDA). Zonnenberg and de Waal summarized which echocardiographic and Doppler-ultrasound measurements, besides clinical parameters, have been used to evaluate the magnitude and clinical relevance of left-to-right shunting through a PDA [2]. Scoring Systems like the one suggested by McNamara and Sehgal include clinical and echocardiographic criteria to define hrPDA [3]. The echocardiographic part of this staging is useful to predict neonatal morbidity and may serve as a guide to clinical decision-making [4]. Resistive index (RI) in the anterior cerebral artery (ACA) was shown to be significantly higher in infants with hrPDA [5].

With frequency domain near-infrared spectroscopy (fd-NIRS) regional cerebral tissue oxygen saturation (rcStO₂) and (together with pulse oximetry data) tissue oxygen extraction (rcFtO₂E) may be monitored noninvasively. In a recent observational study using continuous wave (cw) NIRS, significant differences in cerebral oxygenation over time were observed in infants born below 32 weeks gestation within their first 6 postnatal days [6]. Such an effect, however, was not identified in other recent studies using this technique [7, 8].

To inform future studies and clinical guidelines on PDA treatment, this study aimed to evaluate the absolute cerebral oxygenation of preterm infants besides echocardiographic and Doppler-ultrasound parameters, which are frequently determined to assess the need for PDA treatment.

Methods

This prospective observational cohort study was approved by the institutional research ethics committee and written informed parental consent obtained. Inclusion criteria were gestational age (GA) <37 weeks, birth weight (bw) ≤1500 g and clinical suspicion of hrPDA such as cardiac murmur, bounding pulses, ventilator dependency, metabolic acidosis and increased oxygen requirements. Syndromal anomalies and congenital heart defects except persisting foramen ovale or atrial septal defect were exclusion criteria. Recruitment took place from June 2012 to May 2013 and September 2015 to March 2016 at the tertiary level neonatal intensive care unit of the university children’s hospital, Tuebingen, Germany.

Fd-NIRS-measurements

In infants with clinical indication for echocardiography based on a clinical suspicion of PDA, fd-NIRS was measured at the time of echocardiography. The reflectance mode multi-distance fd-NIRS device OxiplexTS (ISS Inc. Champaign, Illinois, U.S.A.) measures mean intensity (DC), modulation amplitude (AC) and phase shift (PH) at 4 distances and 2 wavelengths and determines absolute values of cerebral oxy-, deoxy-, total hemoglobin concentration and rcStO₂. The optode was placed, as previously described [9], in a temporo-parietal position half-way between tragus and sagittal suture. The optode was held by the examiner for 5 consecutive measurements of 1 min each at either side of the head; it was repositioned between measurement runs [9]. The tissue water content was assumed to be 90% [10]. To exclude effects of tissue inhomogeneity, a quality criteria algorithm was used with r² >0.8 in the linear regression analyses for AC, DC and PH over the four emitter-optode distances as surrogate according to Arri et al. [11]. We decided to use this cut-off because higher cut-offs for r² were unable to increase precision significantly but led to loss of information. To overcome inaccuracy of single measurements [12] we used the mean of up to 10 measurements over 1 min each. Recording frequency was 1 Hz. Intra-observer repeatability was evaluated post-hoc by within-subject SD (SD_W) estimated as square root of the residual mean square by oneway-ANOVA with subject as factor according to Hyttel-Sorensen et al. [13]. The SD_W was ±7% for rcStO₂ and ±0.08 for rcFtO₂E.

Echocardiographic and Doppler-ultrasound measurements

The Parameters assessed were LA/Ao-ratio [14], diameter of the PDA at its narrowest part [15], the left-ventricular-preejection-period-to-ejection-time-ratio, calculated by including 3–4 cardiac cycles (LVPEP/LVET) [16], and the ratio of the velocity time integrals in the large vessels aorta and pulmonary artery (VTI_Ao/VTI_PA). The VTI_Ao was recorded from an apical-5-chamber-view, the VTI_PA in a parasternal short axis. We assumed that, in the absence of congenital heart defects, this ratio correlates with the ductal left-to-right shunt. After visualisation of the whole course of the PDA, its diameter was measured at its narrowest part (identified via colour-Doppler in the high left-sided parasternal “ductal” view and the suprasternal view) and measured in B-Mode to avoid the influence of gain-settings on the PDA-width. RI in celiac artery (CA) [17] and ACA [18] were measured as well. Based on our previous analyses on repeatability of echocardiographic parameters [19], mean values of repeated measurements were assessed whenever possible (i.e., in 18/22 infants, in 4 patients only single measurements were available).

All measurements were performed with a Toshiba “Aplio” using a 6.5 MHz phased array transducer (Toshiba Medical Systems, Otawara-shi, Tochigi-ken, Japan) or a Zonare ZS3 using C10–3 curved-phased array transducer (Zonare Medical Systems, Inc., Mountain View, CA, U.S.A.). For calculation of velocity time integrals, the former device enables automatic detection while the latter device requires manual circumscription of the Doppler wave form.

Cardiorespiratory monitoring and laboratory investigations

During measurements, heart rate (HR) and peripheral arterial oxygen saturation (SpO₂) were monitored in all patients via pulse oximetry (Radical 7; Masimo Corporation, Irvine, CA, U.S.A.) and the SpO₂ was targeted at 90–95% if on supplemental oxygen and at > 89% if no supplemental oxygen was used. Averaging and recording intervals were 2 s each. As for fd-NIRS measurements, we calculated means for each 1-min measurement of these parameters. Blood hemoglobin concentration (Hb in g/dL) from clinically indicated whole blood counts was extracted from patients’ charts if determined within ±12 h of NIRS-measurements or by linear interpolation of the two adjacent Hb concentrations.

Definition of hrPDA

According to the clinical standard in use in the unit, hrPDA was defined if a left-to-right shunt through a PDA was confirmed by echocardiography and at least 3 of the following 6 criteria were met:

• 1. LA/Ao-ratio >1.5

• 2. PDA diameter ≥1.5 mm/kg bodyweight

• 3. Need of respiratory support (mechanical Ventilation or continuous positive airway pressure with supplemental oxygen)

• 4. Reverse or zero end diastolic flow in ACA (=RI_ACA ≥ 1)

• 5. Reverse or zero end diastolic flow in CA (=RI_ CA ≥ 1)

• 6. LVPEP/LVET <0.32

Infants with left-to-right shunt through a PDA meeting less than 3 of the above listed criteria were classified as hiPDA (hemodynamically irrelevant) and allocated, together with infants without a PDA, to the no-hrPDA group.

Statistical analyses

RcStO₂ was extracted and rcFtO₂E calculated from rcStO₂ and SpO₂ data according to Naulaers et al. [20]. Results were screened for potential confounding factors (GA, BW, age at measurement (AAM), gender, Hb, small for gestational age (SGA)) by Spearman-Rho/Pearson correlation coefficient and Fisher’s exact test, as appropriate. If a statistically significant influence was identified on univariate analysis, rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E were normalized for the median of this confounding factor.

Patients were stratified into 2 groups: no-hrPDA and hrPDA according to echocardiographic and clinical parameters (see definition of hrPDA). Demographic, neonatal and echocardiographic parameters were tested for significant group differences using t-, Mann-Whitney-U and Fisher’s exact test, oneway-ANOVA or Welch-Test, as appropriate.

RcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E were tested for statistically significant differences with oneway-ANOVA after confirmation of normal distribution (Shapiro-Wilk) and homogeneity of variances (Levene-statistics).

A p-value below.05 was set to indicate statistical significance. Data are presented as median and interquartile range (IQR) or mean and ± standard deviation (±SD) if not noted otherwise. Where appropriate, 95% confidence intervals (CI) were added. SPSS-Statistics (Version 24.0.0.0, IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, U.S.A.) was used for statistical analyses.

Results

Demographic and neonatal parameters

Twenty-four infants were included in the study. One infant with a BW of 1550 g was included inadvertently due to a body weight at the time of measurement of 1465 g (hiPDA). Two infants were excluded: one infant of 23 weeks GA, BW 360 g, due to fulminant sepsis a few hours after inclusion leading to its demise (hrPDA), so that cerebral oxygenation and hemodynamics could have been corrupted, the other (GA 26 weeks, BW 745 g) due to a ventricular septal defect found during his study echocardiography (hiPDA). Demographic and clinical data of the 22 preterm infants analysed in this cohort are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1 Neonatal characteristics and influence factors

Three infants in the hrPDA group had indomethacin within 24 h prior to measurements (0.1/0.2/0.4 mg/kg BW/day, respectively). Overall, 5 patients needed inotropes and 6 had medical therapy for PDA closure according to the clinical standard in use in the unit. No infant underwent surgical closure of PDA.

Echocardiographic und Doppler-ultrasound measurements

A left-to-right shunt through PDA was identified by colour-Doppler-ultrasound in 12/22 measurements. PDA-diameter at the narrowest part could rarely be measured (n = 6) due to difficulties visualizing the PDA in its complete course in B-mode. PDA staging classified 6 PDAs as hrPDA and 6 as hiPDA. All 6 parameters used to define hrPDA were relevantly different between groups. Mean VTI_Ao/VTI_PA in hrPDA vs. no-hrPDA was 1.43 ±0.56 (95% CI 0.84, 2.02) vs. 0.93 ±0.24 (95% CI 0.80,1.06), p = .085 (Table 2).

Table 2 Echocardiography/Doppler-ultrasound results

NIRS and confounding factors

The oxygen transport capacity of the blood represented by Hb concentration was identified as a confounding factor on rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E by Spearman-Rho (p = .022 and .004, respectively). Pearson correlation showed a significant influence as well (p = .023 and .003, respectively), supporting a linear relationship. We thus normalized rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E for Hb using the linear regression equation:

$$ {\mathrm{normalized}\ \mathrm{rcStO}}_2=1,13{12}^{\ast}\left(\mathrm{medianHb}-\mathrm{patientHb}\right)+{\mathrm{measured}\ \mathrm{rcStO}}_2;{\mathrm{r}}^2=0.2338 $$

and

$$ {\mathrm{normalized}\ \mathrm{rcFtO}}_2\mathrm{E}=-0.01{53}^{\ast}\left(\mathrm{medianHb}-\mathrm{patientHb}\right)+{\mathrm{measured}\ \mathrm{rcFtO}}_2\mathrm{E};{\mathrm{r}}^2=0.3669 $$

After normalization for a median Hb value of 13.8 mg/dl, the overall mean rcStO₂ was 57 ±5% (95% CI: 55%, 60%) and mean rcFtO₂E 0.40 ± 0.05 (95% CI 0.37, 0.41), respectively. Mean RcStO₂ of hrPDA vs. no-hrPDA infants was 54 ±5% (95% CI 49%, 59%) vs. 58 ±5% (95% CI 56%, 61%; p = .102). However, rcFtO₂E mean was 0.43 ±0.05 (95% CI 0.38, 0.48) vs. 0.38 ±0.05 (95% CI 0.35, 0.40; p = .038) (Table 3).

Table 3 Cerebral Tissue Oximetry results

None of the echocardiographic or Doppler-ultrasound parameters correlated significantly with Hb-normalized rcStO₂ or Hb-normalized rcFtO₂E.

Discussion

Using fd-NIRS and normalization for Hb, we found a significant difference in rcFtO₂E, but not in rcStO₂, between infants with vs. without hrPDA in our cohort. As neither Hb-normalized rcStO₂ nor rcFtO₂E correlated with echocardiographic or Doppler-ultrasound parameters, fd-NIRS parameters of cerebral oxygenation may offer additional information and may help to better inform treatment decisions.

In general, a good diagnostic parameter can easily and quickly be determined, has high sensitivity and specificity and is not incriminating to measure in preterm infants. NIRS is a non-invasive technique, and lower cerebral oxygenation within the first 2 postnatal weeks has been associated with poorer neurodevelopmental long term outcome of preterm infants [21]. Suboptimal cerebral oxygenation due to a hrPDA may negatively influence brain growth at term-equivalent age [22] and, at least in animal models, rcStO₂ values below 40% are identified as a risk factor for an impaired neurodevelopment [23].

Data on PDA-related changes in cerebral oxygenation are still controversial, although an impact on cerebral oxygenation has been identified in several studies. In a recent prospective observational trial involving 380 infants of <32 weeks gestation studied during their first 6 days postnatal days, Dix et al. found significant differences in cerebral oxygenation over time [6]. In line with these data, rcFtO₂E showed a statistically significant difference between hr- and non-hrPDA, whereas rcStO₂ did not, but this latter observation may be due limited power due to our small sample size. Another explanation might be an effect of (small) changes in arterial oxygen saturation during measurements, which are not addressed by rcStO₂. Chock et al. studied 47 infants with GA below 29 weeks (21 echocardiographically stratified as hrPDA) and found no significant relationship to rcStO₂ [7]. In line with this, others reported data on 20 hrPDA compared with 29 non-hrPDA preterm infants (median GA 27.6 weeks, median BW 980 g) and found no significant effect on rcStO₂ or rcFtO₂E [8]. Older observational trials found a pronounced impact of hrPDA on cerebral oxygenation in infants scheduled for surgical closure [24,25,26,27,28]. In the present cohort, no infants underwent surgical ligation due to a very restrictive policy on surgical PDA closure in our unit.

Contrary to previous studies using cw-NIRS devices, fd-NIRS provides absolute instead of trend values for rcStO₂ under the assumption of a homogenous semi-infinite tissue. Another advantage of this technique is the opportunity of extracting unprocessed optical raw data, enabling the introduction of a quality pre-analytic algorithm for using high quality data for analysis, thereby improving repeatability. A disadvantage is that this instrument is less practical for continuous bedside trend monitoring due to the use of fragile glass fibre cables as well as its non-disposable probe.

Overall mean values for rcStO₂ were within the (lower) normal range [29], taking into account that this “normal range” was established for the first 72 h of life, while our cohort consisted of older preterm infants. Both, device and sensor, but also the clinical suspicion of hrPDA and/or the higher postnatal age may have contributed to these slightly lower values [30].

A variety of confounding factors impacting on cerebral oxygenation as measured with NIRS are known. Growth restriction, gender and gestational age have already been identified [6, 31, 32]. We were unable to reproduce these findings, possibly due to our low sample size. Only Hb concentration was identified as a confounder so that rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E were normalized for median Hb before further analysis. This should be addressed in future investigations. The higher rcFtO₂E observed with hrPDA supports previous suggestions to maintain higher Hb concentrations in infants with hrPDA as part of conservative management [25]. Whether this might have an effect on long term outcome has not been studied yet.

We found no significant correlation between echocardiographic or Doppler-ultrasound parameters and cerebral oxygenation. A large number of different echocardiographic and Doppler-ultrasound parameters are used to quantify left-to-right shunting through, and hemodynamic relevance of, a PDA (summarised in [2]). This is reflected in NIRS-studies on hrPDA and its effect on cerebral oxygenation by relevant differences in hrPDA definition [7, 8, 33]. This substantially complicates comparisons between studies on hrPDA. The cut-offs used here reflect local preferences and the number of parameters tested was limited to reduce examination time and hence study-driven burden on infants.

To our knowledge only Dix et al. identified a significant relation between an echocardiographic parameter (ductal diameter) and rcStO₂ [6]. We were only rarely able to measure PDA diameter due to our strict definition of the most constricted point at the whole course of the PDA in B-mode. In line with our results Dix et al. found no relation between LA/Ao and cerebral oxygenation.

Before embarking on this study, we assumed that the VTI_Ao/VTI_PA-ratio might be another easily determined parameter suitable for quantifying ductal left-to-right shunt under the assumption of a “normal” ratio of Ao to PA valve-area. It is also important to have in mind that it could be corrupted by inter-atrial shunting, which is commonly observed in VLBW infants (and also in 20 of the infants studied here). However, this limitation also applies to LA/Ao ratio, the most commonly used parameter. VTI_Ao/VTI_PA-ratio has a relatively low repeatability and could be corrupted by ductal jet, although it is supposed to allow discrimination between hrPDA and hiPDA [19].

Limitations of this study are its small sample size and that extremely low gestational age infants, who are most likely to develop hrPDA, were under-represented. We have been reluctant to subject the more immature and hence more vulnerable infants to the additional study-related burden.

By contrast, it is a strength of our study that fd-NIRS was used, truly generating absolute values for rcStO₂ and rcFtO₂E and that a rigorous quality assessment of the raw data preceded further analyses. Furthermore, we identified that Hb was an important confounder of cerebral oxygenation in this context and therefore assessed Hb-normalized values of NIRS parameters.

Only 5 patients overall were ever treated for PDA – this reflects the very restrictive approach to PDA treatment present in our unit - others may be more proactive [6].

Conclusions

Oxygen transport capacity of the blood may be taken into account for NIRS data interpretation. In our cohort we found a statistically significant difference in absolute cerebral oxygenation between clinically and echocardiographically defined hrPDA compared to no-hrPDA infants. Furthermore, our data suggest that parameters of cerebral oxygenation might offer additional information for the clinical decision whether or not to treat a PDA in an individual infant. Whether indicating PDA therapy based on echocardiography complemented by data on cerebral oxygenation results in better outcomes should be investigated in future studies.